Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

New Competition From Trains?

Although far behind, it seems the railroad industry may soon challenge truckers in the science of hauling freight. The Wall Street Journal recently published an article focusing on E. Hunter Harrison and his discovery of an

by Staff
June 21, 2000
3 min to read


Although far behind, it seems the railroad industry may soon challenge truckers in the science of hauling freight. The Wall Street Journal recently published an article focusing on E. Hunter Harrison and his discovery of an innovative way to run a railroad. Actually, it’s not that ingenious, but it is making sense in today's competitive freight hauling environment.
Harrison, the executive vice president and chief operating officer of Canadian National Railway Co., is attempting to bring old railroads back to life by creating a freight delivery schedule that is not only precise, but is monitored through every step.
"This isn’t a quality program or e-commerce but a basic change in how to run a railroad," said Harrison. "We follow it religiously."
According to the Wall Street Journal, North American railroads could be a more potent force in the economy if they followed the same routine. Railroads are a low-cost method of transportation for many goods, but customers are still turning to trucks for reliable service more often.

"If customers were more comfortable with railroad service, they would tend to choose rail over truck," said Harvey Levine, a transportation economist in Rockville, Md. "That would benefit the economy in the form of lower prices for consumer goods, less congestion on our nation’s highways and greater fuel efficiency."
A few railroads are already following Canadian National’s lead, reports the WSJ. Union Pacific Corp. has been guaranteeing that perishable shipments from California will reach New York in eight days. Norfolk Southern Corp. soon be able to track on-time performance of each freight car by early next year.
Harrison’s customers say his efforts are beginning to pay off, according to the WSJ. Shipments of chemicals, lumber, paper, food products and other merchandise freight account for more than half the company’s traffic. Canadian National now delivers chemical shipments 90% on time, compared with 67% for the rest of the railroad industry, said Larry Landuyt, rail team leader of DuPont Co., Wilmington, Del.
Still, Canadian National’s on time performance falls short of what the railroads’ chief competitors, the truckers, are able to pull off — delivering goods 98% on time.
"In our industry, providing a 90% on time level of service would get us a one way ticket out the door," said David Gibbs, executive vice president of Celadon, an Indianapolis-based trucking company.
The WSJ also reported that railroads are afraid that operating to a schedule will drive up costs or be underminded by random events, such as storms or mechanical breakdowns, and other railroads are still busy recovering from post-merger service breakdowns.
The science of hauling freight seems to have begun overhauling the railroads, and that can only mean more competition for North American truckers.

More Fleet Management

Illustration with ATRI logo and square blocks spelling out "research"
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeApril 20, 2026

'Beyond Compliance,' Regulations, Driver Coaching on ATRI’s 2026 Research List

The American Transportation Research Institute will examine driver coaching, regulatory impacts — including the "Beyond Compliance" concept —and weather disruptions that shape trucking operations.

Read More →
Brian Antonellis, senior vice president, fleet operations, Fleet Advantage.
Fleet Managementby Jack RobertsApril 17, 2026

Fleet Advantage's Brian Antonellis on the Growing Need to Replace Old Trucks

Fleet Advantage's Brian Antonellis says it's time for fleets to get back to the fundamentals of good maintenance practices. And that includes replacing older, inefficient equipment.

Read More →
Illustration of computer and mobile screens with load matching software superimposed over photo of an oversize load
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 17, 2026

Truckstop.com Adding to Open Deck, Heavy Haul Offerings

Load matching for flatbed, lowbed, oversize and overweight loads can't be automated like basic van freight, but Truckstop.com is adding more high-tech tools to help.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Trucker Path, Truckstop.com partnership expands.
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 14, 2026

Trucker Path, Truckstop.com Expand Load Access Partnership

An expanded Trucker Path and Truckstop.com integration brings more freight opportunities into the TruckLoads app while emphasizing security and network quality.

Read More →
DAT TVI March 2026.
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 14, 2026

Truckload Rates Hit Two-Year Highs as Diesel Costs Surge, DAT Says

Strong March freight demand combined with a spike in fuel costs pushed both spot and contract truckload rates to their highest levels in more than two years.

Read More →
Cloud computing concept background with human and robot hands concept
Fleet ManagementApril 14, 2026

The AI Conversation You Need to Have with Your TMS Provider

Everyone’s talking about AI — but is your transportation management system actually built for it?

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Sharp Transportation tractor-trailer
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 14, 2026

Kriska Buys Fellow Canadian Carrier Sharp Transportation Systems

Being part of KTG will allow Sharp to expand and improve its services.

Read More →
Illustration with stacks of money and a shattered car windshield
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeApril 13, 2026

Bill in House Would Raise Minimum Insurance for Motor Carriers to $5 Million

The Fair Compensation for Truck Crash Victims Act would increase insurance requirements for interstate motor carriers by nearly seven times.

Read More →
FTR market report for February 2026.
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 10, 2026

FTR Trucking Conditions Index Hits Four-Year High in February

Strong freight rates push TCI to 10.2, but FTR expects fuel-price volatility to skew March results.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
C.H. Robinson intermodal.

C.H. Robinson Offers Carriers Relief as Diesel Prices Surge

C.H. Robinson is waiving fees on fuel cards and cash advances for April and May, aiming to help carriers offset rising diesel costs tied to geopolitical instability.

Read More →