Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Pilot Flying J Pushing Back Against Allegations, Some Opt-Out of Settlement

After a few weeks of relative quiet, things have started heating back up between Pilot Flying J and trucking companies that are suing the truckstop chain over allegations it cheated trucking companies out of fuel rebates.

Evan Lockridge
Evan LockridgeFormer Business Contributing Editor
October 30, 2013
Pilot Flying J Pushing Back Against Allegations, Some Opt-Out of Settlement

Photo: Evan Lockridge

3 min to read


Photo: Evan Lockridge

After a few weeks of relative quiet, things have started heating back up between Pilot Flying J and trucking companies that are suing the truckstop chain over allegations it cheated trucking companies out of fuel rebates.

Ad Loading...

The nation’s largest truckstop operator is asking a federal court in Alabama to dismiss a suit against it from Wright Transportation. The Cleveland Plain Dealer reports the suit filed by the carrier relies almost entirely on the FBI affidavit used to secure search warrants against Pilot Flying J that were served in mid-April as part of the FBI investigation. Pilot Flying J is also pushing back against claims by Wright that it violated federal racketeering laws.

Ad Loading...

Pilot Flying J claims Wright was not a target of any such scheme and denies any such scheme existed.

Wright Transportation is one of many companies that reportedly opted out of a settlement reached this summer between trucking companies and Pilot Flying J.

It is estimated about 150 out of Pilot Flying J’s thousands of customers have opted out of the settlement or have plans to file lawsuits against Pilot Flying J claiming they were cheated out of money. Some that are opting out have reportedly already received payments for any money they felt they were owed and say they are satisfied with what they have received. Others, however, are not happy with the settlement.

A fairness hearing over the settlement, estimated to be at least $40 million, plus attorney fees, is set for Nov. 25 in Little Rock, Ark. It includes paying all money that trucking customers feel they are owed, along with interest.

More than two dozen lawsuits have been filed by trucking customers against Pilot Flying J following the raid.

Ad Loading...

So far seven Pilot Flying J employees have pleaded guilty for their roles in the alleged rebate fraud, though none have been sentenced. At least some are reportedly cooperating with prosecutors, with the speculation there will be further indictments. Others have been put on administrative leave by the company.

In a notice published on the Pilot Flying J rebate website a few days ago, it said, “Our field audit team completed its initial review of current manual rebate accounts on June 30, notified almost every customer whose account had a discrepancy, and sent those customers checks for the amount of the discrepancy plus interest. We continue to review and update these accounts.”

The company says it is now finalizing its audit of all other diesel fuel accounts with any type of direct discount agreement with Pilot Flying J from 2005 to date, and expects to complete this process by the end of the year. This also includes a review of Pilot Flying J’s audit process by an independent accounting firm.

Pilot Flying J says customers have the option to have a third-party independent auditor review their records, at no cost, in addition to its internal auditors’ review.

It also notes it has completed the conversion of all manual rebate customers to electronic calculations.

Ad Loading...

“Any customer who has requested to remain as a rebate customer has had their contract confirmed in writing and been placed in an electronic program. This electronic program contains additional policies and procedures to ensure accuracy,” it says.

More Fleet Management

Illustration showing generic graphs and stylized trucking fleet
Fleet Managementby StaffMarch 24, 2026

ACT: Trucking Volumes Rise, Capacity Tightens as Fuel Prices Cloud Outlook

ACT Research data shows volumes hitting a four-year high and supply-demand balance strengthening, but higher oil prices are undercutting tariff relief and tempering optimism.

Read More →
People looking at Wabash display at TMC
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseMarch 23, 2026

Wabash Teams Physical Security With Digital Tech For Better Cargo Visibility

The patent-pending cargo solution integrates a digitally connected cargo door and an intelligent locking system with the TrailerHawk.AI technology platform.

Read More →
Cyberstop column header depicting images related to cybersecurity and rising oil prices
Fleet Managementby Ben WilkensMarch 20, 2026

From Diesel Prices to Cyberattacks: How the Iran War Is Affecting Trucking

The impact of the Iran conflict extends beyond fuel costs, bringing more fraud and cybersecurity risks to the trucking industry.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
ATA President Chris Spear.
Fleet Managementby Jack RobertsMarch 17, 2026

ATA’s Spear Warns Fuel Prices, Trade Policy, and Global Conflict Could Stall Trucking Recovery

Speaking at the TMC Annual Meeting in Nashville, ATA President Chris Spear said trucking faces mounting pressure from rising fuel prices, geopolitical instability, and uncertainty around trade policy.

Read More →
Illustration of author headshot with black-and-white old-fashioned rig in the background

New Entrants, Chameleon Carriers, and Safety: Is It Too Easy to Start a Trucking Company?

More than 100,000 new trucking companies enter the industry each year, but regulators manage to audit only a fraction of them. That churn creates opportunities for inexperienced startups — and for “chameleon carriers” that shut down after safety violations and reappear under new identities. Read more from Deborah Lockridge in this commentary.

Read More →
Panel discussion
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeMarch 12, 2026

Fleet Managers Invited to Apply for Exclusive HDT Exchange Event

HDTX is an intimate event that connects heavy-duty trucking fleet managers with industry suppliers through small-group discussions, educational sessions, and structured one-on-one meetings.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
DAT iPhone Widget.
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseMarch 12, 2026

DAT Launches iPhone Widget to Help Owner-Operators Find Loads Faster

New DAT One feature shows top-paying loads directly on an iPhone’s home screen, helping carriers react faster to spot-market opportunities.

Read More →
Optimal Dynamics Scale screen shot
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseMarch 12, 2026

Optimal Dynamics Launches AI System to Help Carriers Choose Better Freight

Optimal Dynamics says its new Scale platform uses AI agents and optimization to help carriers find and secure freight that improves network balance and profitability.

Read More →
DAT March 2026 trucking conditions.
Fleet Managementby Jack RobertsMarch 12, 2026

DAT: Flatbed Demand Climbs as Van and Reefer Rates Soften

DAT Freight & Analytics data shows tightening flatbed capacity, easing produce markets, and softening van and reefer rates.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
YouTube thumbnail with Mike Roeth of NACFE saying "NACFE's Messy Middle: Which Fuel Wins?"
Fuel Smartsby Deborah LockridgeMarch 11, 2026

Run on Less “Messy Middle” Data Shows Multiple Paths Forward for Truck Powertrains [Watch]

NACFE's Run on Less - Messy Middle project demonstrates the power of data in helping to guide the future of alternative fuels and powertrains for heavy-duty trucks.

Read More →